HITLAY

First Touchdown Scorer — tonight’s NFL first TD picks & odds

Hitlay's model scored 89 NFL first touchdown scorer props for Sunday, November 8's slate — 11 HIT calls, 78 LAY calls across 14 games (NYJ @ KC, HOU @ LAC, CIN @ ATL, DEN @ CAR, DAL @ IND, NYG @ PHI, CLE @ NO, DET @ MIA, GBP @ NE, TB @ CHI, LAR @ WAS, ARI @ SEA, LV @ SF, BUF @ MIN). The strongest touchdown scorer picks are the ones where the model beats the book price by the widest margin; fades are the reverse. Nothing on this page is hand-picked.

Best first touchdown scorer picks — ranked by edge

PlayerMatchupPropLineCallGradeEdge
Amon-Ra St. BrownDET @ MIA1st TD0.5HITB+5.0
Puka NacuaLAR @ WAS1st TD0.5HITC+4.7
Devin SingletaryNYG @ PHI1st TD0.5HITC+4.7
Saquon BarkleyNYG @ PHI1st TD0.5HITC+4.7
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaARI @ SEA1st TD0.5HITC+4.6
Kyren WilliamsLAR @ WAS1st TD0.5HITC+4.4
De'Andre SwiftTB @ CHI1st TD0.5HITC+4.3
Christian McCaffreyLV @ SF1st TD0.5HITC+3.8
Kenneth Walker IIINYJ @ KC1st TD0.5HITC+3.6
Jahmyr GibbsDET @ MIA1st TD0.5HITC+3.4
James CookBUF @ MIN1st TD0.5HITC+0.0

Fades — the model would bet under

PlayerMatchupPropLineCallGradeEdge
Isaiah WilliamsNYJ @ KC1st TD0.5LAYB+7.2
Cade StoverHOU @ LAC1st TD0.5LAYB+7.1
Joe BurrowCIN @ ATL1st TD0.5LAYB+7.0
John Metchie IIIDEN @ CAR1st TD0.5LAYB+7.0
Dak PrescottDAL @ IND1st TD0.5LAYB+6.9

Top first touchdown scorer calls: NYJ @ KC

  1. Kenneth Walker III — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +3.6, 1:00 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: NYG @ PHI

  1. Devin Singletary — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.7, 1:00 PM ET
  2. Saquon Barkley — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.7, 1:00 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: DET @ MIA

  1. Amon-Ra St. Brown — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +5.0, 1:00 PM ET
  2. Jahmyr Gibbs — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +3.4, 1:00 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: TB @ CHI

  1. De'Andre Swift — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.3, 8:20 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: LAR @ WAS

  1. Puka Nacua — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.7, 1:00 PM ET
  2. Kyren Williams — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.4, 1:00 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: ARI @ SEA

  1. Jaxon Smith-Njigba — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +4.6, 4:25 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: LV @ SF

  1. Christian McCaffrey — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +3.8, 4:25 PM ET

Top first touchdown scorer calls: BUF @ MIN

  1. James Cook — 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +0.0, 8:15 PM ET

Last touchdown scorer — model calls

The same model also prices who scores the final TD of each game; the strongest last-TD calls below.

PlayerMatchupPropLineCallGradeEdge
Brady RussellARI @ SEAlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Eric SaubertARI @ SEAlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Teagan QuitorianoARI @ SEAlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
DeeJay DallasBUF @ MINlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Gavin BartholomewBUF @ MINlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Greg DortchBUF @ MINlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Jackson HawesBUF @ MINlast TD0.5HITB+7.3
Max BredesonBUF @ MINlast TD0.5HITB+7.3

How Hitlay makes its touchdown scorer calls

For every touchdown prop on the board, Hitlay compares a model probability of the player scoring against the devigged book probability. When the model rates the outcome meaningfully more likely than the price implies, the call is HIT; when meaningfully less likely, the call is LAY (under or pass). The edge column is that gap in percentage points; letter grades combine edge with book coverage so single-book lines cannot earn a top grade. Only games that have not kicked off yet appear above — every row shows its ET kickoff, and the page is regenerated from the scored board after each refresh.

Touchdown scorer picks — common questions

Who will score the first touchdown tonight?

The model's top first-TD call for Sunday, November 8's slate is Amon-Ra St. Brown (DET @ MIA) 1st TD HIT at 0.5, edge +5.0, 1:00 PM ET. Every row above is a game that has not kicked off yet, so "tonight" means literally tonight — each row shows its ET kickoff. First-TD props are hard to hit (any of ~30 players can score first), which is exactly why a model edge matters more here than on almost any other market.

What are first touchdown scorer odds?

First touchdown scorer odds are yes/no prices on each player scoring the game’s opening touchdown. Because the outcome is decided on the first scoring play, the odds are long — usually +400 to +2500 for skill players — and the book margin is wide. Hitlay converts each price to a devigged probability, compares it to the model’s probability, and grades the gap as an edge in percentage points.

First touchdown scorer vs anytime touchdown scorer — which is the better bet?

Anytime TD props hit far more often (the player has four quarters to score) so they suit steady bankroll building; first-TD props are lottery-shaped with long odds, so a real probability edge is worth much more per dollar but variance is high. Many bettors stake first-TD bets small and anytime bets larger. Hitlay grades both markets identically — edge and coverage — so you can mix them on the same board.

Are first touchdown scorer picks free?

Yes — every first-TD and last-TD call on Hitlay is free to read: the line, the HIT/LAY call, the grade, the edge, and how many books were considered. No account needed, and this page is regenerated from the scored board after every refresh.

Board file 2026-11-07 (ET); slate = upcoming games only. Regenerated daily from the scored board. Not affiliated with the NFL, DraftKings, FanDuel, or PrizePicks — lines shown are from the sportsbooks Hitlay prices. All pages: index.

Board asof Mon, Nov 16 2026 · 04:29 UTC